Pinochet case spurring debate on international laws the. While most criminal cases in germany are on hold amid coronavirus measures, the trial will go ahead as scheduled, albeit with a limited audience allowed in the courtroom and other measures to. R v bow street metropolitan stipendiary magistrate, ex parte pinochet ugarte no 2 was an english legal case which involved the unprecedented setting aside of a house of lords judgment based upon the possibility of bias. Dolores paz cautivo ahumada repeatedly beaten, threats to rape her. On the night of october 16, 1998, london police arrested gen. The ripple effect of the pinochet case transnational institute. However, pinochet died a few days later on 10 december, without having been convicted of any crimes committed during his administration. Forced to be free abroad and at home in part one of this article it was posited that the pinochet case was best understood not as a harbinger of a. Former chilean president augusto pinochet was detained in london on 16 october 1998 in a move that changed the idea of international justice forever.
The 1998 arrest of general augusto pinochet in london andsubsequent. How general pinochets detention changed the meaning of. Fifteen years on, two of the storys key players spanish lawyer joan garces and former amnesty. How general pinochet s detention changed the meaning of justice 16 october 20, 00. The legacy of the pinochet case is a tribute to three decades of creative and persistent. Two germans sentenced in chile for kidnappings under. Secret uk deal freed pinochet world news the guardian. Judgment of the international military tribunal for the trial of german. Mark lattimer and philippe sands eds, justice or crimes. The pinochet precedent how victims can pursue human.
Pdf this article assesses the impact, if any, of spanish and british court. On 28 november 2006, judge victor montiglio, charged with overseeing the caravan of death case, ordered pinochet s house arrest. The extradition of general augusto pinochet human rights. Prosecuting german collaborators of pinochet regime.
Many european countries harbored large south american exile populations, and, like robin cook in the uk, many of the politicians, judges and lawyers in those countries had as students protested the coup in chile. The london arrest of the senator and retired general, augusto pinochet. On october 8, 1999, london magistrate ronald bartle committed general augusto pinochet for extradition to spain where he could stand trial for 34 counts of torture and one count of conspiracy to. R v bow street metropolitan stipendiary magistrate, ex. Associate professor of international law, faculty of law, university of parma, italy. Charges against pinochet were quickly filed across the continent, including belgium, france, switzerland, sweden, germany, and italy. When augusto pinochet, the authoritarian military ruler of chile from 1973 to 1990, was arrested in london on 16 october 1998, it was one of those rare.
Indictment and arrest of augusto pinochet wikipedia. When augusto pinochet, the authoritarian military ruler of chile from 1973 to 1990, was arrested in london on 16 october 1998, it was one of those rare events that sets history off in a new direction. Justice is long overdue for victims of atrocities committed in chiles colonia dignidad. Judge emma arbuthnot refuses to recuse herself in show. Though in a minority of one, lord goff was right in the pinochet case.
Worldwide interest in the progress of the pinochet case was intense and. Two germans sentenced in chile for kidnappings under pinochet dictatorship. In the pinochet case the former head of state of a foreign country has been held. They were acting on a spanish warrant charging the. Two decades ago, chilean dictator augusto pinochet was arrested in london, putting. Wilson fernando valdebenito electric shocks led to his death. Apart from the trial of the germanaustrian nazi adolf eichmann in israel. A court has sentenced two residents of a cagey german community in south chile for their role in kidnapping 50 people in. Most important, some experts say, the pinochet case will test whether britain is willing to let its international human rights commitments prevail over a domestic law giving immunity to heads of. Pinochet arrested in london augusto pinochet the guardian.
Hartmut hopp was colonias physician and right hand man to paul. Many went missing between 1973 and 1990 during the dictatorship of augusto pinochet and relatives are still seeking answers. Remembering victims of the pinochet dictatorship who were forcefully. But as a result of the pinochet case, the notion of sovereignty. Transitional justice and regime support in postwar west germany. Pdf the pinochet case and human rights progress in chile. The second instance is of a judge failing to recuse himself in 1998 during the attempt to extradite former chilean dictator, torturer and executioner augusto pinochet to face criminal charges in. The pinochet case and human rights progress in chile. First trial of accused syrian statesponsored torture opens in. While most criminal cases in germany are on hold amid coronavirus. Pinochet s arrest put human rights issues back in the headlines, giving victims new voice and sending the message that the international community considered pinochet a criminal. Although a dozen cases had been filed against pinochet in chile prior to his arrest, the detention emboldened victims to submit an avalanche of new cases against the. The pinochet case a wakeup call to tyrants and victims alike. Germany s handling of the rumsfeld case will tell us whether the pinochet precedent applies to the leaders of powerful nations as well as weak.
558 158 1650 34 642 21 1296 1063 1620 308 892 1079 1408 483 1092 1441 1303 1033 299 957 1241 1027 859 449 397 146 1442 1252 1087 642 404 474 1251 806 1062